#3180067
Dá bhrí sin, ba cheart measúnú cás ar chás a dhéanamh ar chomhréireacht EoI i gcomparáid le EoO.
A case-by-case assessment of the proportionality of EoI versus EoO should therefore be undertaken.
Filter results
Collections
27 results in 2 documents
#3180074
Sa chleachtas, ní bheidh an teorainn idir EoI agus EoO ar leibhéal an táirge soiléir agus ní dócha go gcuirfear EoI chun feidhme ar fud na n-ionchur uile i dtáirgí mórdhíola.
In practice, the boundary between EoI and EoO at product level will not be clear-cut and EoI is unlikely to be implemented across all of the inputs to wholesale products.
#3180406
forchuireann an NRA oibleagáidí chun EoI a chur i bhfeidhm, nó EoO i gcás ina mbeidh sé suite ag an NRA go mbeadh oibleagáidí EoI díréireach agus gur leor oibleagáidí EoO chun neamh-idirdhealú éifeachtach a áirithiú;
the NRA imposes obligations to apply EoI, or EoO where the NRA has established that EoI obligations would be disproportionate and that EoO obligations would be sufficient to ensure effective non-discrimination;
#1709641
Go háirithe, d'fhéadfadh údaráis rialála náisiúnta a mheas go bhfuil sé níos dóichí, maidir leis an soláthar ionchur mórdhíola do chórais nua ar bhonn EoI, go gcruthófar glansochair leordhóthanacha, agus dá bhrí sin go mbeidh siad comhréireach, i bhfianaise na gcostas incriminteach níos ísle ar bhonn comparáide chun a áirithiú go mbeidh na córais nuathógtha EoI-comhlíontach.
In particular, national regulatory authorities might consider that the provision of wholesale inputs over new systems on an EoI basis is more likely to create sufficient net benefits, and thus be proportionate, given the comparatively lower incremental compliance costs to ensure that newly built systems are EoI-compliant.
#3180070
Go sonrach, d’fhéadfadh NRAnna a mheas gur dóchúla, maidir leis an soláthar ionchur mórdhíola do chórais nua ar bhonn EoI, go gcruthófar glansochair leordhóthanacha, agus go mbeidh siad comhréireach dá réir sin, i bhfianaise na gcostas comhlíontachta incriminteach níos ísle ar bhonn comparáide chun a áirithiú go mbeidh EoI á chomhlíonadh ag na córais nuathógtha EoI-comhlíontach.
In particular, NRAs might consider that the provision of wholesale inputs over new systems on an EoI basis is more likely to create sufficient net benefits, and thus be proportionate, given the comparatively lower incremental compliance costs to ensure that newly built systems are EoI-compliant.
#1709638
Chun dul i ngleic le hiompraíocht idirdhealaitheach nach mbaineann le praghas, agus chun an iompraíocht sin a chosc, is é coibhéis na n-ionchur (EoI) i bprionsabal an bealach is fearr chun cosaint éifeachtach ar idirdhealú a bhaint amach.
In order to address and prevent non-price related discriminatory behaviour, equivalence of inputs (EoI) is in principle the surest way of achieving effective protection from discrimination.
#1709639
Ar an taobh eile de, is dócha go n-eascróidh costais chomhlíonta níos airde as ionchuir mhórdhíola rialáilte ar bhonn EoI ná mar a dhéanfadh as cineálacha eile oibleagáidí neamh-idirdhealaitheacha.
On the other hand, providing regulated wholesale inputs on an EoI basis is likely to trigger higher compliance costs than other forms of non-discrimination obligations.
#1709643
I mBallstáit ina bhfuil líon mór gnóthais mionscála a bhfuil cumhacht shuntasach sa mhargadh acu, féadfaidh forchur EoI ar gach ceann de na gnóthais sin a bheith díréireach.
In Member States with a high number of small-scale undertakings designated as having significant market power, the imposition of EoI on each of those undertakings can be disproportionate.
#3180060
Na buntáistí a bhaineann le coibhéis ionchuir (EoI) i gcomparáid le coibhéis aschuir (EoO), is féidir éagsúlacht mhór a bheith i gceist leo ó tháirge rochtana mórdhíola amháin go chéile.
The advantages of equivalence of input (EoI) over equivalence of output (EoO) can vary considerably from one wholesale access product to the next.
#3180064
Ba cheart do NRAnna measúnú a dhéanamh ar na costais agus na tairbhí a bhaineann le soláthar ionchur mórdhíola rialáilte a fhorchur ar bhonn EoI, i gcomparáid le foirmeacha eile oibleagáidí neamh-idirdhealaithe, go háirithe EoO.
NRAs should assess the costs and benefits of imposing the provision of regulated wholesale inputs on an EoI basis, compared to other forms of non-discrimination obligations, in particular EoO.
#3180065
Cé gur dócha go mbeidh costais chomhlíontachta níos airde i gceist de thoradh EoI rialáilte a sholáthar ná mar a bheadh i gceist le foirmeacha eile neamh-idirdhealaithe, leis an measúnú costais agus tairbhe, ba cheart costais faireacháin fhadtéarmacha NRAnna a chur san áireamh freisin.
While providing regulated EoI is likely to trigger higher compliance costs than other forms of non-discrimination, the cost-benefit analysis should also factor in the long-term monitoring costs of NRAs.
#3180072
I mBallstáit ina bhfuil roinnt mhaith gnóthais mhionscála a ainmníodh mar ghnóthais ag a bhfuil CSM, is féidir go mbeadh forchur EoI ar gach ceann de na gnóthais sin díréireach.
In Member States with many small-scale undertakings designated as having SMP, the imposition of EoI on each of those undertakings can be disproportionate.
#3180339
costais incriminteacha agus moilleanna comhlíontachta a thagann as cur i bhfeidhm EoI nó EoO, lena n-áirítear na costais a bhaineann le faireachán a dhéanamh ar neamh-idirdhealú;
incremental costs and compliance delays resulting from the application of EoI or EoO, including the costs of monitoring non-discrimination;
#3180341
an éifeacht dhearfach, b’fhéidir, a d’fhéadfadh a bheith ag cur i bhfeidhm neamh-idirdhealaithe dhian i bhfoirm EoI nó EoO ar infheistíocht i líonraí fíor-ardacmhainneachta, nuálaíocht agus iomaíocht;
the potentially positive effect the application of strict non-discrimination in the form of EoI or EoO might have on investment in VHCNs, innovation and competition;
#3180346
Go ginearálta, ba cheart do NRAnna údar a thabhairt lena roghanna idir EoI agus EoO ar bhonn táirge mórdhíola ar tháirge mórdhíola, agus imthosca náisiúnta á gcur san áireamh.
In general, NRAs should justify their choices between EoI and EoO on a wholesale product-by-product basis, taking national circumstances into account.
#3180348
Agus cur i bhfeidhm EoI á mheas, ba cheart do NRAnna cuimhneamh ar dtús ar é a thabhairt isteach ag an leibhéal líonra is doimhne is féidir ag a mbeidh iomaíocht éifeachtach agus inbhuanaithe san fhadtéarma.
When considering the application of EoI, NRAs should first consider introducing it at the deepest possible network level at which competition will be effective and sustainable in the long term.
#3180353
Ba cheart do NRAnna an ceanglas sin a fhorchur go háirithe i gcás nach bhfuil neamh-idirdhealú dian bunaithe ar EoI curtha chun feidhme go hiomlán.
In particular, NRAs should impose that requirement where strict non-discrimination based on EoI is not fully implemented.
#3180407
forchuireann an NRA oibleagáidí a bhaineann le hinmhacasamhlaitheacht theicniúil agus sásraí faireacháin iomchuí, a chuirtear i bhfeidhm i gcomhréir le pointí 18 go 24 den Mholadh seo, i gcás nach gcuirtear EoI chun feidhme go hiomlán;
the NRA imposes obligations relating to technical replicability and appropriate monitoring mechanisms, applied in accordance with points 18 to 24 of this Recommendation, where EoI is not fully implemented;
#3180061
I gcás ina suífidh an NRA nach mbeadh EoI comhréireach le haghaidh táirge nó próiseas ar leith, má tá córas EoO dea-dheartha ann, ag a bhfuil faireachán iomchuí agus eochairtháscairí feidhmíochta (KPInna) oiriúnacha/comhaontuithe oiriúnacha ar leibhéal seirbhíse (SLAnna)/ráthaíochtaí oiriúnacha ar leibhéal seirbhíse (SLGanna), is féidir i roinnt mhaith cásanna gur leor an méid sin agus go rannchuideoidh sé le hiomaíocht a fhorbairt a thuilleadh.
Where the NRA finds that EoI would not be proportionate for a given product or process, a well-crafted EoO regime, with appropriate monitoring and suitable key performance indicators (KPIs)/service level agreements (SLAs)/service level guarantees (SLGs), can in many cases be sufficient and contribute to the further development of competition.
#3180062
I gcás EoO agus EoI araon, braitheann éifeachtacht na hoibleagáide neamh-idirdhealaithe ar cháilíocht na tairisceana tagartha go mór; a mhéid atá KPInna, SLAnna agus SLGanna cuimsitheach, éifeachtach agus ina léiriú ar fhíor-riachtanais oibreoirí malartacha; agus éifeachtacht an fhaireacháin agus fhorfheidhmiú na n-oibleagáidí neamh-idirdhealaithe arna ndéanamh ag an NRA.
For both EoO and EoI, the effectiveness of the non-discrimination obligation is heavily dependent on the quality of the reference offer; the degree to which KPIs, SLAs and SLGs are comprehensive, effective, and reflect the real needs of alternative operators; and the effectiveness of monitoring and enforcement of non-discrimination obligations on the part of the NRA.
#3180068
Sa chleachtas, ní mór do NRAnna roinnt tosca a chur san áireamh agus é á chinneadh cé acu is dócha nó nach dócha go gcuirfear an oibleagáid maidir le EoI chun feidhme go héifeachtach, ós rud é go mbraitheann sí ar na táirgí mórdhíola atá i gceist.
In practice, NRAs need to take into account a number of factors when determining if the obligation of EoI is likely to be effectively implemented, as it depends on the wholesale products in question.
#3180313
ciallaíonn ‘coibhéis na n-inchur (EoI)’, i ndáil leis na táirgí rochtana agus na seirbhísí gaolmhara agus coimhdeacha is gá chun na hionchuir mhórdhíola a sholáthar, soláthar na seirbhísí agus faisnéise do chuardaitheoirí rochtana inmheánacha agus tríú páirtí ar na téarmaí agus na coinníollacha céanna, lena n-áirítear praghas agus cáilíocht leibhéal seirbhíse, laistigh de na scálaí ama céanna agus na córais agus na próisis chéanna á n-úsáid, agus leis an leibhéal céanna iontaofachta agus feidhmíochta;
‘equivalence of inputs (EoI)’ means, in relation to the access products and associated and ancillary services necessary for providing the wholesale inputs, the provision of services and information to internal and third-party access seekers on the same terms and conditions, including price and quality of service levels, within the same time scales, using the same systems and processes and with the same degree of reliability and performance;
#3180336
Is é an bealach is cinnte dá bhfuil ann chun neamh-idirdhealú éifeachtach a bhaint amach agus iomaíocht a chur chun cinn, i bprionsabal, EoI a chur i bhfeidhm, lena n-áirithítear cothroime iomaíochta idir gnólachtaí iartheachtacha an oibreora CSM agus cuardaitheoirí rochtana tríú páirtí.
The surest way to achieve effective non-discrimination and promote competition is, in principle, by the application of EoI, which ensures a level playing field between the SMP operator’s downstream businesses and third-party access seekers.
#3180337
I gcás ina gcuimhneoidh NRAnna ar oibleagáid neamh-idirdhealaithe a fhorchur ar oibreoirí CSM de bhun Airteagal 70 de Threoir (AE) 2018/1972, ba cheart dóibh scrúdú a dhéanamh ar cé acu a bheadh nó nach mbeadh sé comhréireach a cheangal ar oibreoirí CSM ionchuir mhórdhíola ábhartha a sholáthar ar bhonn EoI nó EoO.
Where NRAs consider the imposition of a non-discrimination obligation on SMP operators pursuant to Article 70 of Directive (EU) 2018/1972, they should examine whether it would be proportionate to require SMP operators to provide relevant wholesale inputs on an EoI or EoO basis.
#3180342
aon ghealltanas deonach ón oibreoir CSM chun ionchuir mhórdhíola a sholáthar do chuardaitheoirí rochtana ar bhonn EoI nó EoO, fad a chomhlíontar le tairiscint dheonach den sórt sin na coinníollacha a leagtar amach sa Mholadh seo;
any voluntary commitment by the SMP operator to provide wholesale inputs to access seekers on an EoI or EoO basis, as long as such a voluntary offer meets the conditions set out in this Recommendation;
#3180345
I gcás inar comhréireach, ba cheart neamh-idirdhealú dian i bhfoirm EoI nó EoO a chur i bhfeidhm ar an leibhéal nó ar na leibhéil is iomchuí sa slabhra luacha maidir leis na hionchuir mhórdhíola sin a sholáthraíonn an t-oibreoir CSM dá ghnólachtaí iartheachtacha féin.
Where proportionate, strict non-discrimination in the form of EoI or EoO should be applied at the most appropriate level or levels in the value chain to those wholesale inputs which the SMP operator provides to its own downstream businesses.
#3180349
I gcás ina bhforchuirfear rochtain bonneagair innealtóireachta sibhialta i gcomhréir le pointí 30 go 37 den Mholadh seo, ba cheart do NRAnna cuimhneamh go cúramach ar na tairbhí agus na costais a bhaineann le EoI a chur chun feidhme le haghaidh bonneagar innealtóireachta sibhialta, agus aird á tabhairt go háirithe ar an gcaoi a bhféadfadh beart den sórt sin rannchuidiú le hiomaíocht atá bunaithe ar bhonneagar a chumasú.
Where civil-engineering infrastructure access is imposed in accordance with points 30 to 37 of this Recommendation, NRAs should carefully consider the benefits and costs of implementing EoI for civil-engineering infrastructure, taking into account in particular how such a measure could contribute to enabling infrastructure-based competition.